What is Direct-to-Fan Engagement?
“Direct-to-fan” engagement refers to a creator’s ability to connect with their audience directly without relying on social media algorithms. Instead of being dependent on unpredictable changes from major tech companies, creators are building communities of their fans and communicating with them directly. This type of engagement can allow creators to have more control over how they share and monetize their content.
Different Types of Direct-to-Fan Engagement
There are several ways creators can engage with their audience directly, including:
- Subscription-Based Models – Platforms like Patreon, OnlyFans, and Kajabi allow creators to offer exclusive content to subscribers.
- Email Newsletters – Services like Substack enable creators to send content directly to their audience’s inbox.
- Private Communities – Platforms such as Discord and Memberful provide spaces for creators to foster a dedicated fanbase.
- Digital Marketplaces – Services like Gumroad and Shopify allow creators to sell products, courses, or merchandise directly to fans.
- Live Experiences – Hosting exclusive live streams, Q&A sessions, or in-person events through platforms like Zoom or Twitch.
The Shift Away from Algorithm Dependency
Over the last few years, “community building” has become one of the biggest buzzwords in the creator economy—and for good reason. As creators found themselves at the mercy of ever-changing algorithms, the conversation shifted: How can creators build sustainable revenue streams without relying on Big Tech’s algorithmic mood swings?
Due to the potential TikTok ban, many creators started exploring alternative ways to engage with their audiences without relying on unpredictable platforms. But many were looking for alternatives way before the TikTok ban was even being discussed.
Direct-to-Fan Platforms on the Rise
In the past few years, we’ve seen a surge of platforms designed to cut out the middleman and let creators own their audience relationships. Services like Substack, Discord, Dropout, Memberful, Nebula, Bluesky, OnlyFans, Kajabi, Gumroad, and Patreon have all capitalized on this shift.
This year, Patreon released a new report analyzing the creator landscape and the growing potential of direct-to-fan platforms as both engagement boosters and revenue drivers.
Key Findings from Patreon’s 2025 Creator Report
Challenges in Creator-Fan Engagement
- 53% of creators say it is more difficult to reach their followers today than it was five years ago.
- 57% of fans on TikTok spend most of their time viewing content from creators they don't follow.
The Impact of Platform Algorithms
- 78% of creators feel that algorithms significantly influence their content creation.
- 56% of creators say algorithms prevent them from fully exploring their true passions and interests.
The Reality of Creator Burnout
- 75% of creators feel pressured to constantly produce new content to remain visible on platforms.
Growth of the Direct-to-Fan Market
- The direct-to-fan segment of the creator economy is expected to grow from $194 billion in 2025 to over $231 billion by 2027.
- 56% of the potential creator economy’s value is attributed to direct-to-fan interactions.
The Power of Core Fans
- 86% of core fans are likely to join dedicated online communities.
- 80% of fans are inclined to pay for exclusive content or experiences from their favorite creators.
Patreon’s Stats
- 95% of fans are confident they'll see content from their favorite creators on Patreon—higher than YouTube (78%), TikTok (69%), and Instagram (67%).
- Creators' median annual income per fan is 40 times higher on Patreon than on TikTok, with an average revenue of $52 per fan annually on Patreon.
The Future of Creator Revenue: A Diversified Model
These stats make one thing clear: the creator-platform-fan dynamic is shifting. Direct engagement and diversified revenue streams aren’t just perks—they are becoming essential for creators who want more control over their work and income.
However, this shift doesn’t mean abandoning traditional platforms. Instead, many creators are using direct-to-fan services to complement their existing presence, allowing them to build deeper connections and more sustainable income streams while still leveraging the visibility of mainstream platforms.
Read the Full Report
For a more in-depth look, you can read Patreon’s full report here.
Are you a brand looking to take your campaigns to the next level? Get in touch with us to help you scale your YouTube sponsorships.